Booking in the Real World

Pro wrestling fans know that it's worked.

NBA fans think that it's real.

Those are two obvious facts, but their repercussions are less than obvious to many.  The NBA can draw from angles that evoke old time wrestling; modern pro wrestling can't.

The NBA and its broadcast partners learned the value of old time wrestling booking today.  The Cleveland Cavaliers were subject to something akin to a "Loser Leaves the Playoffs" heading in to Game 5 of the NBA Finals last night.  They needed to win three straight times to avoid elimination.

Due to fans believing that the NBA isn't predetermined (which I don't think it is, for the record), the "needs to win out" angle worked.  The 18-49 demographic (demo) rating was 7.6, up a whopping 27% from a shockingly low Game 4 demo rating.  People tuned because there was suspense in whether the season could end.

Due to pro wrestling fans believing that New Japan is predetermined (which it is, for the record), the "needs to win out" angle didn't work for Will Ospreay at Best of the Super Juniors.  New Japan drew about 1,500 fans for a Friday night show that traditionally sells out a 2,000 seat venue, plus standing room.

The simple fact is that fans of pro wrestling can see traditional angles coming.

Fans of New Japan knew that Will Ospreay had to win his Best of the Super Juniors match against Ricochet -- and his next two matches -- in order to stay in contention for the title.  Fans could see the comeback angle coming and they stayed away in numbers.

Booking 'jeopardy' for Will Ospreay had the exact opposite effect that jeopardy is supposed to have.  Jeopardy is supposed to add suspense.  Teetering a contender on the brink of championship elimination has the opposite effect in pro wrestling because there is absolutely no suspense in the result: fans know that the contender has to win in order for the angle to progress.

New Japan drew a sellout crowd (in advance, no less) once true pro wrestling jeopardy kicked in.

Will Ospreay's Best of the Super Junior finals match vs. Ryusuke Taguchi featured traditional pro wrestling suspense ("who will win the title?"), but it also featured advanced suspense for fans who follow the work.  After getting criticized for doing a "synchronized gymnastics routine" earlier in the tournament, Ospreay was destined to attempt a more grounded, traditional match in the finale.  Many knew this, and the "can he do a grounded match?" question added suspense for those fans.

Game 5 of the NBA Finals had enough real suspense to send Raw's demo ratings "fractional" (below a 1.0) in its last hour and Game 6, coming up Thursday, will likely cause Smackdown to hit record lows as well.  Hopefully WWE Creative -- along with pro wrestling bookers everywhere -- will learn how wrestling fans follow angles and avoid booking angles that only work in the real world.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

When Flyers Can't Draw Flies

Will Ospreay and Ricochet had a match on May 27 at New Japan's "Best of the Super Juniors" in Tokyo.  Maybe you've heard. It was the talk of the Internet Wrestling Community (IWC) for days after Vader , a Hall of Famer with a tremendous legacy in Japan, Tweeted critically about a choreographed spot early in the match.  Predictably, IWC sentiment sided with the young blood, while a few old fogies (and people who admire old fogies) defended the big man. Overlooked, at least until the June 6, 2016 Wrestling Observer  was perused, was the fact that the match didn't draw.  Patches of seats at the 2,005 seat Korakuen Hall were visibly unfilled during the match, and the announced attendance was a mere 1,505.  The flyers match couldn't draw flies. Best of Super Juniors ran over two-and-a-half weeks and Ospreay vs. Ricochet are both non-Japanese headliners, so perhaps the lukewarm attendance was predictable.  Though the show was on a traditionally strong drawing
Read more

Tyron Needs Time

It's no secret that UFC is short on star power.  Ronda may be gone.  Conor is definitely on hiatus.  Jon Jones is suspended, and calling him a major star was a stretch to begin with. UFC, which operates more like a pro wrestling promotion than a sports organization, is taking a tried and true tact: they are trying to create new stars. Creating new stars isn't easy, or even simple.  One reason is obvious: nobody knows who the public will embrace.  Another reason is less obvious: people who aren't Chosen can get jealous. Tyron Woodley appears to be a chosen one for UFC.  He accompanied Dana White to the Super Bowl and he has gotten panel time on UFC studio shows.  In many ways, it makes sense.  He wants to be a star.  He doesn't mind hyping his fights.  He is explosive.  His public persona is not reckless. Woodley also has the good fortune of being in the right weight class with the right set of competing Champions.  The Welterweight division has a reputation for
Read more

Elite Means Elite

Names matter, and the name "All Elite Wrestling" matters a lot.  The promotion authored by Cody & the Young Bucks and owned by Shad Khan's son will be Elite, or it will die trying. The term "Shad Khan's son" is hardly music to the money man behind All Elite, Tony Khan.  Sons of successful entrepreneurs rarely enjoy discussion of the fact that their dads made a lot of money.  There is a perception that being such a son comes with inherent advantages.  Vince McMahon says that Shane had to work twice as hard to reach his position, but many fans and journalists simply don't believe it.  Dynasties like the McMahons of wrestling or Rooneys of football are spotlighted.  Cases where the family business is not handed down -- the Denver Broncos' present ownership drama, for example -- are ignored. Shad Khan is relevant to AEW because he is a remarkable man, with a remarkably American success story.  He emigrated from Pakistan, and simply decided to
Read more